Reviewed by Trevor Scott, Director, Ownright Custom Finance
Quick answer
A difficult first mortgage is a first-ranking property loan for a file a bank won't take: credit issues, ATO debt, unusual property, a short deadline or a complex structure. A private first mortgage lender looks at the property, the amount borrowed against it and the exit rather than applying a fixed checklist, so many files banks decline can still be funded.
Key points
- First mortgage means the lender is first in line on the title.
- Difficult usually means the file, the property or the timing, not the idea.
- Private lenders weigh security and exit alongside credit history.
- Business purposes only.
- Ranking
- First mortgage
- Property-secured
- $20k to $5m
- Security
- Residential or commercial property
Not every first mortgage fits a bank’s template. Sometimes the borrower is the problem: a default, an ATO payment plan, a business that lost money last year. Sometimes it is the property: vacant land, a rural holding, a mixed-use building a valuer found hard to compare. Sometimes it is simply the clock. Whatever the cause, being declined for a first mortgage does not mean no lender will write it.
Why do banks decline first mortgages?
Banks score files. If a file trips certain rules, such as recent defaults, unfiled returns or a structure with several entities, it never reaches a person who can use judgement. The decision is mechanical. A private first mortgage lender is a person with an appetite and a view, which is why the same file can get a different answer.
What private first mortgage lenders weigh
- Property type and location, and how readily it could be sold
- Loan to value: lower borrowing against value means more comfort
- Purpose: what the money does for the business
- Exit: a sale, a refinance back to a bank or a defined cash inflow
- The story behind the credit file: a one-off event, now fixed, reads differently from a pattern
Typical situations
- Buying a commercial premises when the bank’s valuation or policy blocks it
- Settling on a deadline that a bank cannot meet
- Replacing a lender that has withdrawn or called the loan
- Buying with a trust or company-group structure a bank doesn’t understand. See complex structures.
- Unusual or rural property. See unusual security.
Questions to ask any lender
- What is the term and how does the exit work?
- Are there fees on arrangement, valuation, early repayment?
- What happens if settlement or repayment is delayed?
- What are the consequences if I miss a repayment?
Write the answers down. Ask your accountant or solicitor to read the offer, especially where it is a business-purpose loan that sits outside consumer credit protections.
An illustrative example
Illustrative only, not a real client. A building company wants to buy the workshop it leases. The bank declines because of an ATO payment plan and an older default. A private lender writes a short-term first mortgage against the workshop. Two years on, with lodgements current, the company refinances to a bank.
Preparing a stronger application
Even a tricky file benefits from preparation. A short cover note helps a lender see the logic:
- What happened: two or three honest sentences on the credit or tax issue.
- What changed: the fix, such as lodgements now current or a customer collected.
- What you want to do: the property, the amount and the purpose.
- How it ends: the exit and the date.
Add the supporting basics: title search, estimated value, existing loan statements and recent bank statements. If lodgements are behind, say so plainly; our page on overdue lodgements explains how lenders treat them.
Costs and terms in context
Private first mortgages are priced for the risk the lender is taking, and are typically shorter than a bank loan. That cost should be weighed against the alternative. If the choice is between paying for a short-term first mortgage and losing a purchase, a contract or a property to a forced sale, the comparison looks different from one made in a calm month. What matters is total cost over the real term, and that the exit is more than a hope.
Where the first mortgage fits in a wider plan
A difficult first mortgage is often one stage. The business takes a private first mortgage, repairs lodgements, builds a clean twelve months of statements and refinances to a bank. Mapping out those stages, with dates, makes the private loan a bridge rather than a destination, and keeps costs under control.
If you want to understand how the different private options compare, our guide to private mortgages for business is a good place to start.
Know the difference between difficult and unfinanceable
Most difficult files can be funded on the right terms. A few cannot, usually because there is no equity, no exit or no repayment capacity. A good specialist tells you early which group you fall into, so you can use your time on solutions that work.
Next step
Whether it’s a purchase, a replacement lender or a deadline that’s closing in, the first step is a plain description of the file. Tell us about the property → We read every enquiry ourselves and call you, with no credit check at this stage.
Our guides are general information and don’t take your circumstances into account.
Ready when you are
Check your options in about 60 seconds
A few quick questions. Asking won't touch your credit file, your details aren't sent to a pile of lenders, and a real person reads every enquiry.
Frequently asked questions
What makes a first mortgage difficult?
Common reasons include defaults or judgments, overdue tax lodgements, ATO payment plans, trust or company-group structures, rural or specialised property, a short settlement deadline, or a bank valuation that came in low.
Can I get a first mortgage on commercial property with bad credit?
In many cases, yes, case by case. A private lender will weigh the property, loan amount against value and exit against the credit issues.
How long does a private first mortgage take?
It varies with the lender, the property and how quickly valuation and documents arrive. We don't promise set timeframes; we aim to tell you early what is realistic for your file.
Will I be able to move to a bank later?
Often that is the plan. Many owners use a private first mortgage while lodgements, credit or trading history are repaired, then refinance to a bank on cheaper terms.