Reviewed by Trevor Scott, Director, Ownright Custom Finance
Quick answer
Since 1 July 2025, general interest charge (GIC) and shortfall interest charge (SIC) incurred on overdue tax are no longer tax deductible, even when the underlying debt is from an earlier year. That means every dollar of ATO interest now costs the business a full dollar after tax. Carrying tax debt on a payment plan has become relatively more expensive, which changes the comparison with paying it out.
Key points
- GIC and SIC incurred on or after 1 July 2025 aren't deductible, whatever year the debt relates to.
- Interest the ATO charged before 1 July 2025 stays deductible under the old rules.
- The after-tax cost of carrying ATO debt has gone up.
- Compare total after-tax cost, not headline figures, when weighing a payout loan.
- Non-cost factors, such as director penalties and credit reporting, often matter more.
For years, one quiet consolation of owing the ATO money was that the interest it charged could be claimed back as a tax deduction. It softened the blow of carrying a tax debt on a payment plan, and plenty of businesses factored it into their thinking without ever saying so out loud.
That changed on 1 July 2025. If your business carries a tax balance, it’s worth understanding exactly what changed and re-running the numbers.
What changed on 1 July 2025?
The ATO’s explanation of the law change, denying deductions for ATO interest charges, is short and clear. Two interest charges are affected:
- General interest charge (GIC), which applies to tax paid late, including amounts on payment plans.
- Shortfall interest charge (SIC), which applies when an amended assessment increases the tax owing.
The key line: no GIC or SIC that arises from 1 July 2025 onwards can be deducted, even where the underlying debt belongs to an earlier income year. The ATO’s media release adds that interest charged before 1 July 2025 remains deductible under the old rules.
So it’s the date the interest is incurred that matters, not the age of the debt. An old BAS balance still accruing GIC today produces non-deductible interest.
Why does non-deductibility make tax debt more expensive?
Because a deduction reduced the real cost. When GIC was deductible, part of every dollar charged came back through a lower tax bill. Now none of it does.
Illustrative only, using round numbers, not real rates or a real business:
| Before 1 July 2025 | From 1 July 2025 | |
|---|---|---|
| GIC incurred over a year | $10,000 | $10,000 |
| Deduction available | Yes | No |
| Tax saved, if the business’s tax rate were 25% | about $2,500 | nil |
| After-tax cost of that GIC | about $7,500 | $10,000 |
The GIC amount itself hasn’t changed in this example. The business simply keeps less of the benefit. For a business carrying a large balance for a long time, the difference adds up.
Does this change the case for a payment plan?
It changes the arithmetic, not necessarily the answer. The ATO’s guidance for businesses that can’t pay on time notes that GIC continues to apply to payment plans and that paying faster reduces the total. With GIC now non-deductible, the reward for paying faster is bigger.
A payment plan still has real advantages: it’s quick to set up, it stops escalation, and it keeps you engaging with the ATO, which matters for credit reporting. It’s often the right first step. What’s changed is that a plan stretched over a long period now costs relatively more than it did.
How do I compare carrying the debt with paying it out?
Fairly, on the same basis. That means comparing total after-tax cost over the same period, then adding the non-cost factors.
Step 1: the cost of carrying the debt. Ask your tax agent to estimate the GIC you’d incur over the remaining plan term if you keep paying as scheduled. Remember it’s all non-deductible now.
Step 2: the cost of a payout loan. Get the full cost of a loan over the same period: establishment costs, ongoing charges and interest. Ask your accountant how those costs would be treated for tax in your business, rather than assuming.
Step 3: the cash-flow difference. Compare the plan instalment with the loan repayment. A loan with a different schedule can free up monthly cash even if the total cost is similar.
Step 4: the non-cost factors. These often decide it:
| Factor | Carrying the debt on a plan | Paying it out with a loan |
|---|---|---|
| ATO as a creditor | Yes, with collection powers | No |
| Risk if a payment slips | Plan may be cancelled; enforcement can resume | Dealt with by the lender under the loan terms |
| Director penalty exposure | Remains for unpaid PAYGW, GST and SGC | Cleared for the amounts paid |
| Credit reporting risk for large debts | Reduced while the plan is compliant | Removed for the paid debt |
| Effect on other finance | Banks often decline with an ATO balance | ATO balance gone from the picture |
The director penalty rules deserve special attention. Where PAYG withholding, GST or super guarantee charge wasn’t reported within three months of the due date, the only way to have a director penalty remitted is for the company to pay the amount in full. For some directors, that alone makes a payout the clear choice.
If you’d like a figure for the loan side of the comparison, start a 60-second enquiry. There’s no credit check when you first enquire.
What kind of loan pays out ATO debt?
Most often, a property-secured business loan. These run from $20,000 to $5,000,000 as first mortgages, second mortgages behind an existing lender, or caveat loans, and the ATO is usually paid directly at settlement. Lenders focus on the property and the repayment plan, so a tax balance that would stop a bank application is routine.
Without property, unsecured and cash-flow options, typically $20,000 to $500,000 and sized on turnover and bank statements, can sometimes clear smaller balances. Our pages on business loans with ATO debt and borrowing while on a payment plan go into detail, and using property equity explains the secured route.
What has the first year taught owners?
With the change now more than a year old, a few patterns are clear from the businesses we speak to:
- The cost shows up at tax time, not on the statement. GIC looks the same on the ATO account, so the hit lands when the accountant finalises the return and the expected deduction isn’t there.
- Long plans feel the most pain. A balance that was meant to run for a year but drifts to three keeps adding interest that gets no relief.
- Old thinking lingers. Some owners still assume a plan is “free money” because of the deduction. It no longer is.
A useful habit is to ask your tax agent for a GIC figure every quarter, alongside the balance. It keeps the true cost visible.
Does Payday Super make this more urgent?
Possibly. From 1 July 2026 employers pay super with each pay cycle rather than quarterly, and the ATO expects contributions to reach funds within seven business days of payday. Super that’s missed becomes overdue much sooner than under the old quarterly system. The ATO’s Payday Super guidance is worth reading if you employ staff.
The practical point for this topic: a business already carrying an old tax balance has less room to absorb a missed super payment. Clearing the old debt, and keeping a small buffer for new obligations, can keep the two from stacking up. Our guide on when the ATO reports tax debt to credit bureaus shows how a growing balance can also trigger a listing.
Are there other ways to reduce what the ATO charges?
A few, and your tax agent is the right person to pursue them:
- Lodge everything on time, even if you can’t pay. It avoids failure-to-lodge penalties and gives the ATO an accurate figure.
- Pay down faster where cash allows, because GIC accrues on the outstanding balance.
- Ask about remission of GIC where there are genuine reasons, such as circumstances outside your control.
- Keep current obligations current. Adding new debt to an old balance makes every option harder.
Why not just pay the ATO down faster from cash flow?
If the business can do that comfortably, it’s often the cheapest option of all, because every extra payment reduces the balance that GIC accrues on. The catch is that most businesses carrying tax debt got there because cash was tight in the first place. Diverting too much cash to the ATO can leave the business short for wages, suppliers and the next BAS, which starts the cycle again. A sensible middle path for some owners is to clear the old balance with a loan and use a small buffer, such as a line of credit, to make sure new obligations are paid on time. The point is to stop the old debt costing non-deductible interest without creating a new problem somewhere else.
Illustrative example: re-running an old decision
Illustrative only, not a real client. A Melbourne landscaping company has been on a long ATO payment plan since before July 2025. When it was set up, the directors reasoned that the GIC was at least deductible. Their accountant points out that all GIC from 1 July 2025 isn’t, and that part of the balance relates to PAYG withholding that was reported late, leaving the directors personally exposed.
They compare the remaining plan, including non-deductible GIC, with a second mortgage over one director’s investment property. The loan pays the ATO in full at settlement, resolves the director penalty exposure and reduces the monthly outgoing. They choose the loan and agree with their accountant to review refinancing to a bank in two years.
Tax debt costing more than it used to? Let’s put a number on the alternative.
We help owners compare the real cost of carrying tax debt with clearing it, and ATO balances of every size are normal for us. A sixty-second enquiry, no credit check when you first enquire, and no lender list on the receiving end. A specialist calls you with the loan side of the comparison.
Please include the ATO balance, whether it’s on a plan, and any director penalty notices. Accurate details give you a comparison you can rely on. See if you qualify →
Ready when you are
Check your options in about 60 seconds
A few quick questions. Asking won't touch your credit file, your details aren't sent to a pile of lenders, and a real person reads every enquiry.
Frequently asked questions
Is GIC still deductible if the tax debt is from before July 2025?
Not for interest incurred on or after 1 July 2025. The ATO says GIC or SIC incurred from that date isn't deductible regardless of which income year the debt relates to. Interest incurred before 1 July 2025 remains deductible.
Does the change affect payment plans?
Yes, indirectly. GIC keeps accruing on a payment plan, and that GIC is now non-deductible, so a plan costs more after tax than it used to.
Is interest on a loan used to pay my tax debt deductible?
That depends on your circumstances and how the loan is used. Ask your accountant how the costs of any loan would be treated for your business before comparing options.
Can I ask the ATO to remit GIC?
The ATO can consider requests to remit GIC in some circumstances. Your tax agent can advise whether a remission request is worth making in your case.
Does this change apply to penalties as well?
The 2025 change is about GIC and SIC. Penalties, such as failure-to-lodge penalties, have their own rules. Ask your accountant about how each item on your statement is treated.
Is it worth checking my plan now that we're a full year past the change?
Yes. Ask your tax agent for a current statement showing how much GIC has built up since 1 July 2025 and what the rest of the plan will add. Seeing the actual non-deductible figure makes the comparison with a payout far less abstract.
How does Payday Super fit in?
From 1 July 2026 super is due with each pay cycle, so late contributions surface sooner. The super guarantee charge has long been non-deductible, so letting super slip adds to the cost of carrying ATO debt.